News Games Store Play Online Downloads Forums Gameplanet
Close
Gameplanet has relaunched. You're looking at the old Gameplanet site. To view the new site, go to www.gameplanet.co.nz.
Gameplanet Gameplanet Network
 

Reviews: PC Games - Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-Earth



Home
   News
     - Archives
   Reviews
     - PC Games
     - Xbox 360
     - PlayStation 3
     - Wii
     - Nintendo DS
     - PSP

   Previews
     - PC Games
     - Xbox 360
     - PlayStation 3
     - Wii
     - Nintendo DS
     - PSP

   Features
   Chat

Downloads
   Demos
   Movies
   Patches
   more...

Forums
   General Gaming
   Open Discussion
   Hardware/Tech
   Buy/Sell/Trade
   more...

Play Online
   Game Servers
   Supported Games

Email Newsletter
   Subscribe
   Past Issues
   more...

Online Store
   PC Games
   PlayStation 2
   Xbox
   GameCube
   more...




Gameplanet Network
   Gameplanet
   GP Forums
   GP Downloads
   GP Store

   Counter-Strike NZ
   Day of Defeat NZ
   Half-Life 2 NZ
   DS Geek
   PS2 Geek
   Xbox Geek



About Gameplanet
About the Team
Contact Us/Advertise

Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-Earth

By Gunner (18 January 2005)

Summary
Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-Earth

Ups: Anything that features New Line Cinema's The Lord of the Rings has to be good. Good graphics and a campaign that melds with the original story.

Downs: Large amount of PC grunt required to get the best out of the big battles. Lack of variety in formations and limited tactical options. No ability to play as the elves or dwarves in the skirmish mode.

Bottom Line: This is a good, solid real-time strategy game that has the added attraction of being based on the Lord of the Rings story. It has loads of action and some well put-together graphics. Be aware, however, that to play the game at its best you require a good PC. Overall, a strategy game that deserves a place in your collection.


Overall rating: 4 out of 5 fists   Great



advertisement
THIS GAME WAS A long time coming, and just like the movies themselves EA had tantalised us with some great clips of in game footage that had a lot of us impressed - both by the graphics and by the amount of units involved in the battles. The early clips of The Lord of the Rings: Battle for Middle Earth promised much and we are happy to say that it has delivered in scope and breadth.

Click for enlargement

The game is set in the time of the Fellowship and allows various modes of play. In single player mode you can elect to play a campaign as either the forces of good or evil. There is also a skirmish mode option which is available for both single- and multi-player. In the campaign mode you are greeted with a beuatifully rendered map depicting the various regions, each broken into zones. Each represents an area to conquer or to travel over.

Every major conflict from the movies is included. You will battle with the fellowship through the mines of Moria, defend the plains of Gondor and stand firm in Helms Deep. When you set out with the fellowship you initially fight alone but as you progress through the campaign you will enlist the help of allies and be able to create units and armies.

Click for enlargement

The basic game setup is in 3D isometric view that you can zoom in and out of as required. Control is through the standard point and click. However, rather than the menu bar at the bottom you are presented with, a palantir serves both as map and unit control. A bit of practise is required to get accustomed to it but you will soon find that it is quite adequate for the small amount of commands you need to give your units.

Click for enlargement

The strategic resource side of the game is not too complex, with each side being required to collect one or two resources to get things moving along. Your city building is limited to a preset area that is of a format familiar to most current strategy games. You have limited building spaces and are forced to make immediate trade-offs between farms and unit-producing buildings. This may not suit some players as you cannot freely build towers etc. to set up your own defensive arrangements. Nonetheless the system works well and with most maps containing more than two or three available settlement sites, you can eventually develop whatever mix of buildings you want.

Upgrades are simplified as well in the game. As time progresses and you produce more units, more options and upgrades either happen automatically or become available to you. If you do upgrade unit abilities such as weapons and armour, you also have to buy them for each unit. This may seem a bit harsh but it does place more importance on the upgrades and which units receive them.

Click for enlargement


Click for enlargement

As you battle onwards your units improve in ability. They can gain standard bearers and become more adept in combat. In campaign mode these units are carried through to the next battle. There is a neat feature where you can upgrade your orc units by setting them to fight each other. As they are a free cost to produce (they are dug up, like potatoes), there is some advantage in doing this.

Variety-wise there are some exciting units and some notable ommissions. You get to see the ents, the oliphants, ogres and the like as well as the normal missile units, infantry and cavalry. Elves make an appearance in the campaign and can be "summoned" as a special ability; however, we would have liked to have had the option to play them and the dwarves as a race in the game.

Click for enlargement

All the heroes and villains make an appearance in the campaign, and within the skirmish game you can also generate them from one of the buildings. Initially they are pretty limited in ability, but as they gain experience more hero abilities become available to them. These include lightning attacks, more powerful attacks and so on. You also gain command points that can apply to the entire battle, which will allow you to call in special units like the elves, heal units or arm your peasants. Progression through the campaign can also gain you more command points to use.

Click for enlargement

Combat is limited in the amount of options available to you. Most units have no variety in formation and tactics is a case of just sending them into battle as a mob and hoping for the best. Battles are usually a confused affair with lots of bodies flying and many casualties. Units die quickly in this game - especially green ones, so it is an ongoing process of building new units to replenish lost ones, or pulling units out to heal them. Ideally we would would have liked to have seen more flexibility to combine and group units into specialised formations that would allow more tactical input into the battles.

Even at easy levels the game's AI can be tough. You need to grab settlements early and produce units and resources quicker to gain the upper hand. As soon as you have lost said upper hand it is a tough road back to win the battle. This style of gameplay may not suit everybody, but the battles are certainly not protracted because of this simplistic strategic model. There is no apparent advantage for terrain types that we could descern either, so overall it is largely a unit bash fest with limited tactical flexibility.

Click for enlargement

Overall the graphics are great with some excellent animated touches to the settlements and buildings. The combat and spell effects are also well put together. On our review PC the game was very smooth, however we did try it on a lesser spec'ed machine and in the bigger battles there was a considerable amount of performance drop. Clearly, to get the best from the game you need a high end machine.

Click for enlargement


Click for enlargement

The in game movie sequences from the films are a nice touch and the voiceovers by the actors themselves meld well into gameplay. All of this makes for a well presented and polished product.

Although this is a simplistic game that will appeal to a lot of players, the lack of micro management and the sparse amount of tactical options may ultimately disappoint some hardened strategy players. We certainly found it fun to play and the added appeal of The Lord of the Rings backdrop makes it a product we can highly recommend.




  • Check out the Official Site.


  • Details
    Developer:

       Electronic Arts

    Publisher/Manufacturer:

       Electronic Arts

    Links:

       Official Web Site



    System Requirements:

      •  Windows XP/2000
      •  1300 MHz CPU
      •  256 MB RAM
      •  4000 MB available hard drive space
      •  DVD-ROM

    Review System:

      •  Windows XP Home
      •  Intel Pentium 4 3400 MHz
      •  1 GB RAM
      •  DVD-ROM
      •  ATI X600 128 Meg
      •  Audigy

    in Reviews
    Lost Odyssey (X360)
    Lost Odyssey (X360)
    Mistwalker's second foray into the RPG genre is every bit as ambitious as their first. We loved Blue Dragon, and we're happy to report Mistwalker and Feel Plus (another subsidiary if Microsoft) have pulled out all the... full story

    Also: Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games (DS), Devil May Cry 4 (X360), Burnout Paradise (X360), Futuretronics Wireless Racing Wheel (PS2) ...


    More

    in Previews
    Frontlines: Fuel of War (X360)
    Frontlines: Fuel of War (X360)

    Lost Odyssey (X360)

    Civilization Revolution (PS3)

    Don King Presents: Prizefighter (X360)

    Army Of Two (X360)



    More

    News Headlines

    Tuesday, 19 February
    Imperium Romanum: Developer Interview

    The Witcher Enhanced Edition Announced


    Monday, 18 February
    Lost: Via Domus website relaunched

    LEGO Indiana Jones Web game online


    Friday, 15 February
    TrackMania to be released on Nintendo DS

    Red Alert 3 Announced


    Thursday, 14 February
    Gameplanet To Relaunch Website

    Gran Turismo 5 Prologue Website Launched

    Sony Announce Valentines Day Activities


    Wednesday, 13 February
    Mass Effect for PC in May

    EA & Maxis To Ship Spore In September


    Tuesday, 12 February
    NZ's Popular PC Gaming Team adds Xbox 360 divisions

    2008 Blizzard Entertainment Worldwide Invitational Announced

    FlatOut Head On – Official PSP Demo due for Release 22 February 2008


    Monday, 11 February
    Grand Theft Auto IV Website Launched

    Viking: Battle for Asgard Official Website Launched

    Academy Awards Top Honours to Call of Duty 4, Bioshock and The Orange Box


    Friday, 8 February
    Gameplanet Jackass Competition Closes - Winner Notified

    Duke Nukem Forever Release In 2008?

    Guitar Hero Marathon Relay Achieved at Guinness World Record Gamer's Edition Launch

    More
    Email Magazine - Situation Report
    SITUATION REPORT is your weekly round up of the latest gaming news and information - delivered direct to your inbox.

    Just enter your name and email address below to subscribe now!






    Powered by EXPIO
    Back to top
    Copyright © 2000-2009 Gameplanet (NZ) Limited. All rights reserved.