News Games Store Play Online Downloads Forums Gameplanet
Close
Gameplanet has relaunched. You're looking at the old Gameplanet site. To view the new site, go to www.gameplanet.co.nz.
Gameplanet Gameplanet Network
 

Reviews: Xbox - Breakdown



Home
   News
     - Archives
   Reviews
     - PC Games
     - Xbox 360
     - PlayStation 3
     - Wii
     - Nintendo DS
     - PSP

   Previews
     - PC Games
     - Xbox 360
     - PlayStation 3
     - Wii
     - Nintendo DS
     - PSP

   Features
   Chat

Downloads
   Demos
   Movies
   Patches
   more...

Forums
   General Gaming
   Open Discussion
   Hardware/Tech
   Buy/Sell/Trade
   more...

Play Online
   Game Servers
   Supported Games

Email Newsletter
   Subscribe
   Past Issues
   more...

Online Store
   PC Games
   PlayStation 2
   Xbox
   GameCube
   more...




Gameplanet Network
   Gameplanet
   GP Forums
   GP Downloads
   GP Store

   Counter-Strike NZ
   Day of Defeat NZ
   Half-Life 2 NZ
   DS Geek
   PS2 Geek
   Xbox Geek



About Gameplanet
About the Team
Contact Us/Advertise

Breakdown

By (16 September 2004)

Summary
Breakdown

Ups: Engaging story, told from the first-person perspective. Hand-to-hand combat is well executed, if a little tricky at first to get to grips with.

Downs: The first-person perspective can sometimes be limiting for melee combat, or disorienting. The controls are not designed for easy use. The visuals are well below the acceptable standard for the Xbox.

Bottom Line: Breakdown is a game that introduces some interesting new ideas to the FPS genre. Unfortunately the game is let down by being overly short and linear, as well as some annoying control issues, making it hard to recommend.


Overall rating: 3 out of 5 fists   Good



advertisement
THE FIRST-PERSON SHOOTER (FPS) genre has seemed to stagnate lately, offering little in the way of innovation, especially for console gamers. Breakdown seeks to address that with a shift away from the heavy weaponry and large-scale battles to a more close-up style with the focus on hand-to-hand combat. With its experience with the Tekken series Namco was a good developer to evolve this idea. It also sets out to provide a stronger narrative than most in the genre, immersing the player in the lead character's story through the use of in-game cut-scenes that blend in with the characters actions. While Breakdown largely succeeds in achieving these goals it falls down on some of the basics of the FPS genre.

Click for enlargement

Derrick Cole is the main character, a wounded soldier revived through the use of cyborg experiments. Little is known about him or his situation at the start of the game, and it slowly unfolds as the game progresses. Derrick wakes up in a research facility, unable to remember too much about what happened to him or how he got there. He is reoriented with the world through a short series of tasks, which handily teach the basic controls to the player. Soon after though the facility is attacked by soldiers, and the struggle to escape begins. Along the way new abilities are discovered, which is just as well after the appearance of a series of superhuman foes.

Click for enlargement

Hand-to-hand combat was always going to be tricky in a first-person game, and to their credit Namco have done a quite a good job with it. The shoulder buttons control the basic jabs and punches, with kicks and other moves activated with a combination of those and the left analogue stick. Namco have obviously used their experience with the Tekken series for Breakdown and as the game progresses more and more combos can be unlocked, resulting in quite an impressive move list by the end of the game.

While the melee combat controls are a fairly well done, the rest of the control system isn't exactly geared towards ease of use. Most actions require several button presses, even something simple like picking up items or climbing a ladder. Picking up an item, for instance requires the player to look at the item (or person or object carrying it), press the 'X' button to target, press 'X' to pick the item up, and press 'X' again to accept the item. While this is being done players cannot move or look around, even once the item is picked up, leaving them open to attack. Games shouldn't be this cumbersome, and using multiple button presses to open a door or retrieve some dropped ammo isn't impressive.

Click for enlargement

As well as the hand-to-hand combat Derrick can use the few weapons he finds. Through most of the game he will only have the use of a pistol, and machine-gun and grenades, with a couple of other weapons available late in the game. The focus definitely is on the melee combat with the large impressive weapons found in most FPSs missing. Further highlighting this focus are the rather simple controls for using weapons. With no crosshair or any accurate way of aiming players are forced to use the auto-targeting system. This though is quite restrictive, markedly cutting down Derrick's range of movement while the targetting is active.

Click for enlargement

Graphically Breakdown is a mixed bag. There are some quite neat touches, like the shadow effects used for Derrick, the portrayal of a lot of the action around him from a first-person view and neat effects like the gas mask. However there are also some quite glaring negatives that make the overall look of Breakdown appear bad. The amount of flickering and jaggies present hasn't really been seen to this extent in an Xbox game for a while, and the overall design and lack of texturing have created a very bland looking title. While visuals don't necessarily make or break a game, in a game like this where a believable story through the eyes of a character is trying to be woven they do take away a lot if not up to scratch.

Click for enlargement

Adding to this problem is the overall blandness of the level design. Breakdown is very linear, with a lot of the game played in long straight corridors with only one entry and exit. Much of the game is played in and around a large building complex, leading to rather characterless levels, although later in the game this does improve. The sterility of the building also translates to the insipid look of each of the rooms and corridors. Many of the walls are dull beige, with rooms and corridors lit by uniform lighting. Occasionally there is something a little more interesting, such as a smoky fire but on the whole the levels seem to be designed to put players to sleep. Taking a closer look at a lot of the features in a room doesn't improve the situation either. Many of the accoutrements of a room look like they have been painted on and virtually none of the items are interactive.

Click for enlargement

What does impress is the dedication to the first-person outlook that Breakdown has. Virtually all the cut-scenes are viewed from the view of Derrick, beginning with the opening scene waking up in the facility. Players only ever get to see Derrick's face when he looks in a mirror. Even while playing the camera does a good job of staying in character, rocking back if Derrick is punched or falling right back if he is knocked down. While at times this can be disorienting this does lead to a more immersive game. The only real problem with this view is the relative lack of visibility, leaving the player at a disadvantage at some points, for instance in a melee fight with more than one opponent players can take hits from the side or rear without realising anyone is there. This does add to the difficulty in what can often be quite a challenging game, but it does force the player to think a little more about their actions rather than the gung-ho attitude of a lot of first-person games.

Click for enlargement

On the whole the sounds in Breakdown are quite adequate, but don't really add anything to the game. Voice acting is reasonably good apart from the odd character that seems rather flat. Unfortunately there are large parts of the game where the soundtrack is almost non-existent. In between the ambient noises there is a lot of silence, which can seem rather odd at times. It doesn't help that the sound effects in the game aren't always good or accurate. The noise of weapons is quite good but there are some glaringly bad effects as well, such as the gentle sowing machine hum of a helicopter.

Click for enlargement

The big disappointment with Breakdown is that it could have been so much more. The premise of the story and the hand-to-hand control in fist-person are quite original and engaging but these tend to fade into the background as the less attractive features vie for the player's attention. Breakdown just doesn't quite measure up, either on its own or compared to the competition. It doesn't help that the game feels like it was built around a gimmick, rather integrating that gimmick into an existing game. Also letting it down is the relative brevity of Breakdown, with little to entice players to play again apart from the extra difficulty settings. While it is hard to recommend Breakdown we do applaud Namco for taking a chance on putting some originality back into a genre that badly needs it.




  • Check out the Official Site.


  • Details
    Developer:

       Namco

    Publisher/Manufacturer:

       Electronic Arts

    Links:

       Official Web Site



    in Reviews
    Lost Odyssey (X360)
    Lost Odyssey (X360)
    Mistwalker's second foray into the RPG genre is every bit as ambitious as their first. We loved Blue Dragon, and we're happy to report Mistwalker and Feel Plus (another subsidiary if Microsoft) have pulled out all the... full story

    Also: Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games (DS), Devil May Cry 4 (X360), Burnout Paradise (X360), Futuretronics Wireless Racing Wheel (PS2) ...


    More

    in Previews
    Frontlines: Fuel of War (X360)
    Frontlines: Fuel of War (X360)

    Lost Odyssey (X360)

    Civilization Revolution (PS3)

    Don King Presents: Prizefighter (X360)

    Army Of Two (X360)



    More

    News Headlines

    Tuesday, 19 February
    Imperium Romanum: Developer Interview

    The Witcher Enhanced Edition Announced


    Monday, 18 February
    Lost: Via Domus website relaunched

    LEGO Indiana Jones Web game online


    Friday, 15 February
    TrackMania to be released on Nintendo DS

    Red Alert 3 Announced


    Thursday, 14 February
    Gameplanet To Relaunch Website

    Gran Turismo 5 Prologue Website Launched

    Sony Announce Valentines Day Activities


    Wednesday, 13 February
    Mass Effect for PC in May

    EA & Maxis To Ship Spore In September


    Tuesday, 12 February
    NZ's Popular PC Gaming Team adds Xbox 360 divisions

    2008 Blizzard Entertainment Worldwide Invitational Announced

    FlatOut Head On – Official PSP Demo due for Release 22 February 2008


    Monday, 11 February
    Grand Theft Auto IV Website Launched

    Viking: Battle for Asgard Official Website Launched

    Academy Awards Top Honours to Call of Duty 4, Bioshock and The Orange Box


    Friday, 8 February
    Gameplanet Jackass Competition Closes - Winner Notified

    Duke Nukem Forever Release In 2008?

    Guitar Hero Marathon Relay Achieved at Guinness World Record Gamer's Edition Launch

    More
    Email Magazine - Situation Report
    SITUATION REPORT is your weekly round up of the latest gaming news and information - delivered direct to your inbox.

    Just enter your name and email address below to subscribe now!






    Powered by EXPIO
    Back to top
    Copyright © 2000-2009 Gameplanet (NZ) Limited. All rights reserved.